Insurance Fraud Investigations: How Long They Take and What to Expect
If you have received a letter from your insurance company requesting additional documentation, been asked to attend a recorded interview, or learned that your claim has been referred to a special investigation unit (SIU), you are likely worried about what happens next.
That uncertainty is understandable. Insurance fraud investigations in New Jersey can involve multiple agencies and unfold across separate legal tracks. A limited insurer review may end relatively quickly, while a complex investigation can remain open for years. No single timeline applies to every case.
This guide breaks down how a New Jersey insurance fraud investigation works, including what triggers an investigation, who conducts it, what the process looks like, and how you can engage Dughi, Hewit & Domalewski’s Insurance Fraud Lawyers to protect yourself throughout.
How insurance fraud investigations begin
An insurance fraud investigation may begin with an insurer’s internal review, before law enforcement becomes involved or the policyholder knows that fraud is suspected.
New Jersey requires insurers writing private passenger automobile or health insurance to maintain approved fraud-prevention plans that include SIU functions. Insurers also have obligations to report suspected insurance fraud to the state’s Bureau of Fraud Deterrence and Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor. These reporting obligations do not depend on notifying the policyholder first.
Circumstances that may prompt additional scrutiny include:
- Inconsistencies between a claim and other records
- A loss that occurred shortly after a policy was issued or its coverage increased
- Tips from third parties
- Prior claims history
- Financial circumstances that suggest a possible motive
An SIU may investigate these circumstances and refer or notify state authorities, depending on its findings. An internal flag does not necessarily mean the insurer has established fraud or that criminal charges will follow.
A discrepancy or mistake does not, by itself, establish criminal insurance fraud. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6(a), the state must establish a knowing material misstatement or omission connected to an insurance transaction.
Who conducts the investigation: DOBI, insurers, or law enforcement?
Insurance fraud investigations in New Jersey do not follow a single chain of command. Understanding who is involved and what role they play can make the process easier to follow.
- Your insurance company: The insurer reviews the claim, requests supporting information, and determines whether coverage or payment is owed. An SIU may investigate suspected fraud and submit information to state authorities.
- The Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI): DOBI’s Bureau of Fraud Deterrence investigates suspected violations of the Insurance Fraud Prevention Act and handles civil and administrative enforcement.
- The Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor (OIFP): OIFP operates within the New Jersey Office of the Attorney General. It investigates and prosecutes insurance fraud and coordinates with other enforcement authorities.
- County prosecutors: County prosecutors may investigate and prosecute insurance fraud, sometimes with assistance or coordination from OIFP.
DOBI and OIFP jointly review reports to determine whether civil enforcement, criminal investigation, or both are appropriate. These proceedings can run on parallel tracks rather than moving through a fixed sequence.
Federal authorities may also become involved when the alleged conduct falls within federal jurisdiction, including certain schemes involving federal healthcare programs. Healthcare-related allegations can raise distinct issues, including those addressed by the firm’s healthcare fraud defense practice.
What to expect during an insurance fraud investigation
Your experience during an investigation depends on who is involved and what they are investigating. Several steps may arise, and understanding their purpose can help you respond appropriately.
Recorded statements and document requests
At the insurer or SIU stage, you may be asked to provide a recorded statement and supporting documentation. Depending on the claim, requests may include financial records, medical records, authorizations, or other information relevant to the insurer’s review.
Your obligations depend on the policy, the request, and applicable law. Information provided to an insurer may also become relevant to a government investigation, so it is important to understand both your cooperation obligations and any potential criminal exposure.
Examination Under Oath
An examination under oath, or EUO, is sworn questioning an insurer may request under the policy. An attorney typically conducts it, and a court reporter records it. Your statements may later become evidence in a coverage dispute or government proceeding.
Failure to comply with a valid EUO requirement can jeopardize coverage. When criminal exposure is possible, an attorney can help assess both your contractual obligations and the risk of self-incrimination. Declining to answer on Fifth Amendment grounds may be strategically required to avoid criminal liability, but does not necessarily prevent the insurer from denying coverage for noncooperation.
Subpoenas and state-level requests
A government investigation may involve subpoenas requiring documents or testimony. N.J.S.A. 17:33A-10 authorizes DOBI’s commissioner or a designee, after consultation with the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor or a designee, to compel evidence.
Government proceedings may continue alongside the insurer’s separate claim investigation. A subpoena should not be ignored; counsel can review its scope, response deadline, and any available objections.
Criminal investigation activity
A criminal investigation may involve witness interviews, surveillance, subpoenas, or searches authorized by a warrant. You may not receive advance notice of investigative activity.
If investigators contact you, distinguish a request for a voluntary interview from a subpoena or other legal requirement. Before giving a substantive statement, seek advice from an attorney about your rights and obligations.
How long these investigations take and what drives the timeline
No standard completion deadline applies to every New Jersey insurance fraud investigation. A straightforward insurer review and a complex criminal investigation are different processes, and one may continue after the other ends.
Several factors can affect the timeline:
- Scope of the allegations: Multiple claims, transactions, or alleged misrepresentations may require a broader review than a single disputed statement.
- Type and volume of records: Medical records, billing data, financial transactions, and electronic communications may take time to obtain and analyze.
- Number of parties involved: An investigation involving several policyholders, providers, businesses, or witnesses can require more coordination.
- Overlapping proceedings: An insurer’s coverage review, DOBI enforcement, and a criminal investigation may proceed simultaneously and reach different outcomes.
- Response timing: Gathering records and responding to valid requests can affect the review’s pace. Coordinate responses with counsel so deadlines, policy obligations, and potential criminal exposure are addressed together.
Claims-handling deadlines are a separate issue
An open fraud investigation does not necessarily eliminate the insurer’s claims-handling obligations.
For applicable property and liability claims, N.J.A.C. 11:2-17.7 establishes requirements for prompt investigation, payment periods subject to exceptions, and written explanations when additional time is needed. It also requires periodic updates in specified circumstances. Those requirements do not establish a deadline for completing a criminal investigation.
When a civil or regulatory case becomes criminal
Being under investigation does not automatically mean criminal charges are coming. A matter may lead to civil or administrative enforcement, criminal prosecution, both, or no enforcement action.
Civil and criminal investigations can begin together. Under N.J.S.A. 17:33A-9, DOBI’s Bureau of Fraud Deterrence and OIFP jointly review reports to determine which warrant civil enforcement, criminal investigation, or both. If the bureau later obtains previously undisclosed information suggesting a reasonable possibility of criminal wrongdoing, the statute requires an immediate referral following the required internal review.
Violations of the Insurance Fraud Prevention Act can result in civil penalties and other financial consequences. A civil settlement does not, by itself, prevent criminal prosecution.
Criminal charges under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6 depend on the conduct involved, the number of acts, and the aggregate value of benefits wrongfully obtained or sought:
- Fourth degree: Certain false statements used to obtain out-of-state auto insurance when the person principally resides in New Jersey or principally garages the vehicle here. The maximum penalties are 18 months in prison and a $10,000 fine.
- Third degree: Insurance fraud under subsection (a) that does not meet the second-degree criteria. The prison range is three to five years, with a fine of up to $15,000.
- Second degree: Five or more acts of insurance fraud involving an aggregate value of at least $1,000 in property, services, or other benefits wrongfully obtained or sought. The prison range is five to ten years, with a fine of up to $150,000.
These are ordinary statutory penalties, not a prediction of an individual sentence. Each act can constitute a separate offense, including multiple fraudulent acts within a single document.
How to conduct yourself during an active investigation
How you respond when you have been accused of insurance fraud can affect both the insurance claim and any related enforcement proceedings. A few practical guidelines apply throughout the process.
Get legal advice promptly and do not ignore deadlines
If you suspect fraud allegations, seek legal advice before giving a substantive statement or attending an EUO. Do not ignore document requests, subpoenas, hearing notices, or policy deadlines.
An attorney can assess what requires a response, whether an extension or objection is appropriate, and how to address competing coverage and criminal-defense concerns. Insurer cooperation requirements and government demands are not interchangeable.
Preserve everything
Do not alter, delete, or destroy records, documents, messages, or other information related to the claim. Preserve original materials and discuss document-retention steps with your attorney.
Be truthful and do not guess
Do not speculate, fill gaps in your memory, or repeat an answer you now know is inaccurate. If an earlier statement needs clarification or correction, discuss how to address it with your attorney.
Limit discussions about the investigation
Avoid discussing the facts on social media or with people who do not need to be involved. Conversations with friends, family, or coworkers generally do not receive the same legal protections as confidential communications with your attorney.
If you need to communicate with an employer, licensing authority, insurer, or another party, ask counsel how to handle any applicable reporting obligation.
How an attorney can help
An attorney can become involved before charges are filed, while the insurer is still reviewing the claim, or after a government investigation begins.
The firm’s insurance fraud defense attorneys can help assess the allegations and develop a response tailored to the matter. Depending on the stage, legal assistance may include:
- SIU phase: Communicating with the insurer, assessing document requests and policy obligations, presenting information that addresses suspected discrepancies, and being present with you during any statements
- DOBI/OIFP stage: Communicating with investigators, responding to subpoenas, representing you in enforcement proceedings, and assessing whether a civil resolution is available
- EUO: Preparing you for questioning, attending the proceeding, and advising you about the scope of questioning, policy obligations, and potential self-incrimination risks
- Criminal stage: Reviewing the evidence, investigating potential defenses, challenging the prosecution’s case where appropriate, and evaluating available resolutions
Counsel can help clarify misunderstandings and present relevant information, but cannot guarantee that a referral or prosecution will be avoided. Insurers must still comply with applicable reporting obligations.
Consult with an attorney
Being contacted in connection with an insurance fraud investigation does not automatically mean criminal charges will follow. It does mean that your response should account for policy obligations, legal deadlines, and the possibility of overlapping proceedings.
At Dughi, Hewit & Domalewski, our criminal defense and government investigations team represents clients in state and federal criminal matters, government investigations, grand jury investigations, and subpoena responses.
Contact us today to discuss your situation.







